The Times Publishing House’s Fight Against Free Speech

As has been reported at Spicy IP and Legally India the Times Publishing House – which owns Times of India – is threatening to sue for defamation a 22 year old student blogger for one of her posts on Spicy IP. The case, which is succinctly recounted on the above links, stems from a post in which she comments on the Times Publishing House’s ongoing litigation with the Financial Times Ltd over a trademark dispute.

The NUJS student’s post in question mostly just recounts articles from the Mint updating readers on the status of the litigation. Nothing sensational. (Read it). Yet, it apparently sent the Times Publishing House into a tizzy, causing them to be “shocked and surprised” as their lawyers at K Datta and Associates empathized in their notice to the college student.

This action by the Times Publishing House follows on the heals of a defamation suit by NATCO against Shamnad Basheer for a post he also wrote for Spicy IP. This trend of corportate houses trying to crack down on bloggers through defamation suits who they feel cast them in an unflattering light (or any light at all) is deeply disturbing and one of the more significant threats to free speech in India today – not to mention the development of a vibrant legal academy. The courts should send a clear signal that such intimidating tactics will not be tolerated.

Spicy IP does a good job at cataloging all the relevant material so I will let you read through their post on the matter if you like. I’ll just end by saying that I was surprised to learn from the Times Group’s notice to the student in para 7 that their position is that when there has been a factual inaccuracy in an article that the proper response is to “publish the true and correct facts . . . with the same prominence with which you had published the [original] impugned article.” This admission I am sure will be welcome to anyone who has ever had any factual inaccuracy reported about them in the Times of India that might have caused them to be “shocked or surprised” and we can look forward to many front page above-the-fold apologies from Times of India in the future. 

Written by
Nick Robinson
Join the discussion

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

  • This issue has pivotal importance in the realm of free speech.But most print as well as electronic media and social networking groups ignore the news (except Hindu)well done Nick

  • Dear blogger friend,

    We take this opportunity to inform you that your blog has been listed in the Directory of Best Indian Blog, 2012-13 edition.

    We have been bringing out this Directory since 2011 and the present one is its third edition.

    If you are hearing of ITB for the first time and are curious about it, you might like to see our blog selection criteria and the process we follow for selecting blogs for this Directory on

    We don't know how much you care for your blog’s listing, but we assure you that we work hard to select blogs for the Directory. ITB badges on hundreds of Indian blogs are a testimony of the trust bloggers pose on us.

    Our hearty congratulations on your maintaining a quality blog, and we wish that your blog reaches new heights.

    Best wishes!

    IndianTopBlogs team


    1. If you have any reservations about your blog's inclusion in the Directory, do email us and we’d remove your blog from our listing.

    2. If you feel like, do place ITB badge on your blog. It is purely voluntary but we are sure it will add value to your blog in terms of reputation, popularity and position on search engines.

    3. We have started a blogging community in Google Plus, with a few members to start with. We intend to make this community a place to exchange ideas about the craft of blogging. The Indian blogging community will benefit if you agree to join the G+ community page. Joining is very simple: Kindly go to the URL given below, join / sign in to Google Plus and click on 'ask to join'.

    4. We are posting this message here as we could not find your email ID on the blog. Or did we miss it?