The New Telecom Act: What’s the Fuss?

Summary: This article examines the newly enacted Telecommunications Act and delves into the concerns and uncertainties surrounding its provisions. 

The  Telecommunications Act 2023 (“the Act”)  received Presidential assent on 24th December 2023, and has now become law. The Act replaces the Indian Telegraph Act, of 1885, the Indian Wireless Telegraphy Act, of 1933, and the Telegraph Wires (Unlawful Possession) Act, of 1950. The Act is aimed at modernising the telecommunications sector by replacing crude interpretations of ancient laws. The Act is aimed at regularizing licensing, spectrum allocation, and providing a uniform and modern code to aid the expansion and development of the telecommunications sector. However, the Act has been subject to a fair share of criticism and scrutiny regarding its scope of application, and critics argue that it can be used to enable mass surveillance. This article will discuss the apprehensions and haze surrounding the provisions of the Act. 

The worry surrounding an overbroad definition

The Telecommunications Act as a sine qua non includes a definition of ‘telecommunication’ in Section 2 (p). The definition has been criticised for being broad and potentially including all forms of digital communication under the sun, including Overthe-Top (OTT) services like WhatsApp and Telegram. The Act under section 20 (2) gives the government the power to intercept and detain messages or suspend services in instances of public emergency, ensuring public safety, sovereignty, and integrity of India. 

Section 22 (2) allows the government to collect, store, analyse, and disseminate ‘traffic data’ involved with telecommunications networks. Traffic Data, as defined by the Section, means “any data generated, transmitted, received or stored in telecommunication networks including data relating to the type, routing, duration or time of a telecommunication.” While the procedure for such actions by the government is to be provided for in the rules as and when they are framed, critics argue that the government is undermining personal freedoms and Parliamentary debate by relegating important aspects of the functioning of the Act to delegated legislation. 

The Indian Telegraph Act provides for the interception of messages in the interest of India’s sovereignty and integrity, security of the State, public order, or friendly relations with foreign States. This provision was challenged before the Supreme Court in PUCL v. Union of India on the touchstone of Article 19 of the Constitution. The Court laid down guidelines that were consolidated in section 419A of the Indian Telegraph Rules, 1951, and the Temporary Suspension of Telecom Services (Public Emergency or Public Safety) Rules, 2017. These two provisions are on the lines of the PUCL judgement and the authority to intercept messages is ideally given by the Secretary to the Government of India in the Ministry of Home Affairs at the Union level, and the Secretary to the State Government in charge of the Home Department at the State level. Hence, the provisions regarding interception of messages are not novel, but may have far-reaching implications due to the broad definition of ‘telecommunications’. 

The Interception Issue

India’s system of interception resembles that of the United Kingdom but diverges in material aspects. Unlike the United States and even Australia to an extent, in both India and the UK, the authority to intercept messages comes from the Executive branch of the government. In the UK, interception of communication is governed by the Investigatory Powers Act, 2016 (IPA), and the Interception of Communications Code of Practice.

However, in the UK, the IPA makes provision for the post of an Investigatory Powers Commissioner who makes an annual report to the Prime Minister which is subsequently tabled before the Parliament and is available to the public. In Australia, apart from National security warrants which are issued by the Attorney-General, law enforcement warrants are issued by Judges or members of criminal tribunals. 

The issue concerning the wide definition in the Indian Act plagues the UK too. The definition of ‘telecommunication system’ in the IPA is similarly broad, and the UK’s attempts to regulate telecommunications have been consistently contentious, with difficulties in defining emerging technologies to ensure that legislation does not over or under-regulate. The EU has dealt with similar issues by drawing a distinction between Electronic Communications Services (ECS), such as standard voice and text-message services, and Information Society Services (ISS), which include OTT services.

More recently, the UK has witnessed companies that provide messaging applications threaten to exit the country over proposed disclosure, interception, and retention requirements in the form of the Online Safety Bill, which attempts to protect children from harassment and sexual abuse. Technology companies like WhatsApp and Apple market their products on the back of guaranteed user security. Apple’s iMessages and WhatsApp communications are end-to-end encrypted, which ideally means that intercepted messages would be intelligible and hence communication is secure and inaccessible to the companies themselves. The UK government seeks to gain access to these communications and technology companies are being forced to weigh the cost of complying with UK law on one hand and exiting the market on the other. Concerns over propagation of sexual abuse, and national security are not invalid, but the need of the hour is an informed understanding of proportionality, and the scope of interception necessary to achieve this aim. This is especially important in India since interception is authorised by the executive and not a judicial or independent body.

Europe has seen a slew of challenges to data retention and interception regimes. In Big Brother Watch v. United Kingdom, the Grand Chamber of the European Court of Human Rights held that the UK’s bulk interception regime under RIPA, 2000 was in breach of the European Convention on Human Rights. The Court held that the interception regime did not have adequate independent safeguards, and was thus, incompatible with the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR). This was remedied in 2023. In 2023, the UK Court of Appeal considered a challenge to the IPA’s bulk data retention provisions. The Court found that the Act had sufficient safeguards generally but found for the claimants on a few grounds, namely protection of journalistic material and data from bulk personal datasets. Hence, in the UK, exhaustive clauses on procedural safeguards have passed the muster of the ECHR, and Courts have required high standards of checks and balances for government interception to be held lawful.

In India, such exhaustive provisions are lacking, and the true extent of privacy protection or invasion will be evident only when the relevant rules are framed. Furthermore, the government has recourse to section 69-A of the Information Technology Act, 2000, a provision which has been held to be constitutional by the Supreme Court, and has been used to restrict access to applications (apps) in the past.

In 2020, the government banned hundreds of applications, including the popular app TikTok, and ordered app-stores to remove access to them on the grounds of national security. As shown, there is an undeniable intersection between the Internet and the Telecommunications sector, but the government has tried and tested tools to exercise executive discretion. The broad definition of telecommunications will come into sharper focus as and when either Parliament or the Executive seek to regulate service providers further. 

Search and seizure

Section 42 of the 2023 Act is similar to section 7 of the Wireless Telegraphy Act, 1933. It gives authorised officers the power to search any building, vehicle, aircraft, or place in which the officer has reason to believe that any unauthorised telecommunication network or telecommunication equipment, or radio equipment is being concealed. 

Under section 165 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, an officer in charge of a police station or an officer in charge of an investigation may execute a search of a place within their jurisdiction if the officer has reasonable grounds to believe anything necessary for such investigation may be found at such a place. The caveat is that the officer must believe that the object of such a search cannot be obtained without undue delay. In such a manner, the requirement of a search warrant may be avoided. 

In State of MP v. Paltan Mallah, the Supreme Court held that an illegal search does not exclude the evidence recovered per se. The evidence that is recovered may be admitted by the Court after assessing whether there is a violation of an express statutory provision or Constitutional freedom and does not cause undue prejudice to the accused. The Courts in India generally tend to favour the inclusion of evidence rather than exclusion on technical grounds. While the power under section 42 of the Act appears to be wide and prone to misuse, it is not unprecedented. 

Biometric Information

Section 3 (7) of the 2023 Act provides that authorised entities which provide telecommunication services must identify their users through biometric-based identification. Under section 4 of the Telegraph Act, telecom service providers may identify their users through Aadhaar, Passport, or any other officially valid document or mode of identification as notified. The Supreme Court’s decision in Puttaswamy v. Union of India held that linking Aadhaar with SIM cards was unconstitutional. Pursuant to this judgement, service providers were ordered to accept other documents that act as Proof of Identity and Proof of Address for the Know Your Customer (KYC) process.  The Telegraph Act explicitly provided that the subscriber had the ultimate choice amongst the three modes of identity verification. Currently, the Department of Telecommunications has phased out paper KYC and shifted to e-KYC for the issuance of new SIM cards. 

In Puttaswamy, the Supreme Court held that mandatory linking of SIM cards with Aadhaar did not meet the test of proportionality. In paragraph 283, the Court explicitly referred to the sensitivity of biometric information and how biometric data can be exploited for commercial gain. The Court held that Aadhaar was not the least intrusive form of identity verification and thus the linkage was struck down as unconstitutional. It may be argued that biometric data can be a legitimate form of verification if adequate safeguards are provided for and the clear link between curbing misuse and fraud related to SIM cards and biometric verification is established. However, the Act does not specify any such safeguards and the provision may be subject to the same outcome as that in Puttaswamy. 

The Court in Puttaswamy laid down a three-fold test that legislation must meet to pass the muster under Article 21- (i) legality (ii) the existence of a legitimate state aim; and (iii) proportionality which ensures a rational nexus between the objects and the means adopted to achieve them. This may be difficult to prove in light of the recent and continuous reports of data breaches and attacks targeting Indian government institutions.

In 2023, it was reported that Aadhaar and Passport details of 815 million Indians was compromised and up for sale. As circumstances stand, the government is caught in a catch-22 situation- if biometric data is indispensable to regulating the telecommunications sector, the government is not in a position to convincingly prove that data that is collected is secure. If these data breaches are to be downplayed, the third limb of the Puttaswamy test is compromised.

Conclusion

This piece has sought to shed light on the controversial aspects of the new Telecommunications Act, and show that some of the provisions of the Act do not raise novel concerns, but simply reproduce existing apprehension. Provisions related to search and seizure, and interception of messages are recurring issues. The concerns regarding mass surveillance turn on the government’s treatment of OTT platforms and other service providers who are not conventionally considered to be standard players in the telecommunications industry.

The extent to which the new Telecommunications Act encroaches on the Right to Privacy will be definitive only after the government frames the rules for collection, interception and storage of data. This would imply that the Act itself becomes a framework for a comprehensive set of Rules. The test of proportionality is still the yardstick by which the Telecom Act will be measured and challenged if need be. The need of the hour is informed and incisive discourse on the specifics of the legislation, and the legitimate interests that vest in interception need to be highlighted and discussed in order to ensure that the people are adequately informed of the crucial balance that is at stake. India can look towards the West and the Global North to pre-empt the pitfalls that plague interception and data regimes.

The Telecommunications Act can find redemption only by redefining the existing telecom regulation regime through the Rules by instituting safeguards, well-reasoned provisions, and a measure of accountability in a historically unaccountable regulatory scheme.

Aditya Panuganti is a second-year student at NLSIU, Bangalore, and an analyst for LAOT. 

[Ed Note: This article has been edited by Sohina Pawah and published by Harshitha Adari from the Student Editorial Board.]

 

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
47 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
trackback
The New Telecom Act: What’s the Fuss? – NALSAR University of Law | Library | eLibrary
1 year ago

[…] Posted byAditya Panuganti […]

punta cana airport to hard rock
punta cana airport to hard rock
1 month ago

Very well presented. Every quote was awesome and thanks for sharing the content. Keep sharing and keep motivating others.

Reciprocal Link Building
Reciprocal Link Building
24 days ago

I very delighted to find this internet site on bing, just what I was searching for as well saved to fav

HÜSEYİN YAVUZ
HÜSEYİN YAVUZ
16 days ago

Daha önce araştırıp pek Türkçe kaynak bulamadığım sorundu Elinize sağlık eminim arayan çok kişi vardır.

MEHMET
MEHMET
16 days ago

You’re so awesome! I don’t believe I have read a single thing like that before. So great to find someone with some original thoughts on this topic. Really.. thank you for starting this up. This website is something that is needed on the internet, someone with a little originality!

Mariana Tanner
Mariana Tanner
16 days ago

I truly appreciate your technique of writing a blog. I added it to my bookmark site list and will

REZZAN
REZZAN
16 days ago

This is really interesting, You’re a very skilled blogger. I’ve joined your feed and look forward to seeking more of your magnificent post. Also, I’ve shared your site in my social networks!

FATİH
FATİH
16 days ago

I really like reading through a post that can make men and women think. Also, thank you for allowing me to comment!

Sofia Sharp
Sofia Sharp
16 days ago

This is really interesting, You’re a very skilled blogger. I’ve joined your feed and look forward to seeking more of your magnificent post. Also, I’ve shared your site in my social networks!

ÖZLEM
ÖZLEM
16 days ago

Pretty! This has been a really wonderful post. Many thanks for providing these details.

ERGÜN
ERGÜN
16 days ago

Nice post. I learn something totally new and challenging on websites

BİŞAR
BİŞAR
16 days ago

This was beautiful Admin. Thank you for your reflections.

ESRA
ESRA
16 days ago

This was beautiful Admin. Thank you for your reflections.

AYŞE
AYŞE
16 days ago

I am truly thankful to the owner of this web site who has shared this fantastic piece of writing at at this place.

Leila Branch
Leila Branch
16 days ago

Hi there to all, for the reason that I am genuinely keen of reading this website’s post to be updated on a regular basis. It carries pleasant stuff.

JALE
JALE
16 days ago

I just like the helpful information you provide in your articles

Jazmine Marquez
Jazmine Marquez
16 days ago

This was beautiful Admin. Thank you for your reflections.

UĞURAY
UĞURAY
16 days ago

Nice post. I learn something totally new and challenging on websites

Jakobe Villarreal
Jakobe Villarreal
16 days ago

Verdiginiz bilgiler için teşekkürler , güzel yazı olmuş

SERDAR
SERDAR
16 days ago

Çok yararlı bi yazı olmuş hocam teşekkür ederim .Sizin yazılarınızı beğenerek okuyorum elinize sağlık.

FUNDA
FUNDA
16 days ago

I really like reading through a post that can make men and women think. Also, thank you for allowing me to comment!

YASER
YASER
16 days ago

bu konuda bu kadar net bilgiler internette malesef yok bu yüzden çok iyi ve başarılı olmuş teşekkürler.

GÜLSEN
GÜLSEN
16 days ago

I’m often to blogging and i really appreciate your content. The article has actually peaks my interest. I’m going to bookmark your web site and maintain checking for brand spanking new information.

Leila Branch
Leila Branch
16 days ago

Bu konu hakkında bilgi vermeniz çok güzel. Genellikle türkçe içerikler az oluyor fakat böyle güzel içerikler görmek ve okumak çok zevkli.

ŞERİF
ŞERİF
16 days ago

very informative articles or reviews at this time.

ERKAN
ERKAN
16 days ago

gerçekten çok yararlı bi konu teşekkürler

ERCAN
ERCAN
16 days ago

Hocam detaylı bir anlatım olmuş eline sağlık

AYCAN ÖZDEN
AYCAN ÖZDEN
16 days ago

naturally like your web site however you need to take a look at the spelling on several of your posts. A number of them are rife with spelling problems and I find it very bothersome to tell the truth on the other hand I will surely come again again.

Kinley Sims
Kinley Sims
16 days ago

çok bilgilendirici bir yazı olmuş ellerinize sağlık teşekkür ederim

AYŞEGÜL
AYŞEGÜL
16 days ago

I really like reading through a post that can make men and women think. Also, thank you for allowing me to comment!

SULTAN
SULTAN
16 days ago

This is really interesting, You’re a very skilled blogger. I’ve joined your feed and look forward to seeking more of your magnificent post. Also, I’ve shared your site in my social networks!

ÖZHAN
ÖZHAN
16 days ago

I truly appreciate your technique of writing a blog. I added it to my bookmark site list and will

AYŞEGÜL
AYŞEGÜL
16 days ago

Ne zamandır web sitelerim için aradığım içeriği sonunda buldum. Bu kadar detaylı ve net açıklama için teşekkürler.

YUSUF ALPER
YUSUF ALPER
16 days ago

There is definately a lot to find out about this subject. I like all the points you made

SÜHEYLA AYÇA
SÜHEYLA AYÇA
16 days ago

Great information shared.. really enjoyed reading this post thank you author for sharing this post .. appreciated

HAÇÇE
HAÇÇE
16 days ago

Hocam Ellerinize Saglık Güzel Makale Olmuş Detaylı

TURĞUT
TURĞUT
16 days ago

I just like the helpful information you provide in your articles

Leandro Turner
Leandro Turner
16 days ago

I truly appreciate your technique of writing a blog. I added it to my bookmark site list and will

HALİL
HALİL
16 days ago

You’re so awesome! I don’t believe I have read a single thing like that before. So great to find someone with some original thoughts on this topic. Really.. thank you for starting this up. This website is something that is needed on the internet, someone with a little originality!

ONAT
ONAT
16 days ago

Hocam Ellerinize Saglık Güzel Makale Olmuş Detaylı

Ulises Flores
Ulises Flores
16 days ago

Hi there to all, for the reason that I am genuinely keen of reading this website’s post to be updated on a regular basis. It carries pleasant stuff.

Ella Hull
Ella Hull
16 days ago

naturally like your web site however you need to take a look at the spelling on several of your posts. A number of them are rife with spelling problems and I find it very bothersome to tell the truth on the other hand I will surely come again again.

Marlon Chapman
Marlon Chapman
16 days ago

Makaleniz açıklayıcı yararlı anlaşılır olmuş ellerinize sağlık

UFUK
UFUK
16 days ago

I’m often to blogging and i really appreciate your content. The article has actually peaks my interest. I’m going to bookmark your web site and maintain checking for brand spanking new information.

MUSTAFA ERSAGUN
MUSTAFA ERSAGUN
15 days ago

I just like the helpful information you provide in your articles

saranya
saranya
7 days ago

I very delighted to find this internet site on bing, just what I was searching for as well saved to fav

Isabelle U. C. Fernandez
Isabelle U. C. Fernandez
4 days ago

Looking forward to your next post. Keep up the good work!

47
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x