Mr.Vivek Reddy’s well thought-out response (carried in the comments section of my earlier post) requires a detailed critique. While I have posed certain specific questions to him, I am using this opportunity to further provoke …
Continue readingCategory: Uncategorized
ACADEMICS AND THEIR IMPACT ON THE JUDICIARY
Just came across Adam Liptak’s interesting piece titled “When Rendering Decisions, Judges Are Finding Law Reviews Irrelevant” in the New York Times. Liptak captures an interesting judicial perspective on how relevant US law review articles …
Continue readingA reluctant ‘stay’ on the basis of flawed reasoning
The language of the Supreme Court’s stay of section 6 of the Central Educational Institutions (Reservations in Admissions) Act, 2006 makes for strange reading. In the last paragraph, it says: “In the background of what …
Continue readingLong Live Vote Bank Politics!: A Polemics
The Supreme Court’s interim judgment in the Ashoka Kumar Thakur vs. Union of India and Ors. granting a stay on the OBC reservations in Central Educational Institutions requires a careful study and I intend to …
Continue readingSupreme Court stays UPA govt’s OBC quota policy
Yesterday, the Supreme Court appears to have issued an order staying the UPA government’s initiative to impose new quotas for OBCs. Here are reports of the stay order and the Court’s general observations in the …
Continue readingDebating the virtues of ‘Judicial Consensus’ and the role of dissents in judicial opinions
In the comments section of the previous post, Vivek Reddy has this to say while discussing the Coelho case: “One interesting thing about the Ninth Schedule judgment is that it was a unanimous judgment. In …
Continue readingRecent pieces of interest in the Economic and Political Weekly
Recent issues of the Economic and Political Weekly contain several interesting articles that are either directly or incidentally related to the law. I am not sure when EPW moved to this new format (where it …
Continue readingIn Defence of Proportional Representation
In my earlier post on corruption debate-I, I emphasized the dire need to replace the first-past-the-post system with the PR. I am glad that HT editor, Vir Sanghvi has endorsed my suggestion in his column, …
Continue readingAn analysis of recent Supreme Court rulings on crimes against women
Today’s Indian Express carries a column by a member of the Delhi Commission for Women, Ranjana Kaul, who provides an analysis of recent Supreme Court rulings focusing on IPC provisions relating to crimes against women. …
Continue readingThe Indian Supreme Court’s mixed record on human rights issues in anti-terror cases
A recent post by V. Venkatesan highlights stark contradictions in the Indian Supreme Court’s overall record on human rights issues relating to terrorism. In particular, the description of the way in which the Supreme Court …
Continue reading